University of Leicester law expert wins landmark Court of Appeal consumer rights case

Dr Ebenezer Adodo, Associate Professor of Commercial Law at Leicester Law School.

A University of Leicester law academic has successfully argued a landmark Court of Appeal case which strengthens the rights of consumers returning laptops and other electronic devices bought online.

Dr Ebenezer Adodo, Associate Professor of Commercial Law at Leicester Law School, argued the appeal on behalf of the consumer in Dr Ebenezer Adodo v Argos Limited.

The Court of Appeal ruled in favour of the consumer, overturning earlier judgments which had found that the right to withdraw from the purchase of a laptop had been lost after the device was switched on and tested.

The judgment has important consequences for consumers who buy products including PCs, laptops, tablets and iPads online, test them after delivery and subsequently seek to exercise their right to cancel the purchase.

The case centred on the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 and whether testing a device meant a consumer lost their right to withdraw from the contract.

Dr Adodo argued the appeal before Lady Justice King, Lady Justice Andrews and Lord Justice Foxton. The Court of Appeal accepted his argument and allowed the appeal.

Dr Adodo said: "This is a significant judgment for consumer rights. Buying online inevitably means you cannot examine a product in the same way you could do in a shop, so the ability to test it at home is an important protection. I’m delighted the Court of Appeal has recognised that principle and that this case will provide much-needed clarity for consumers and retailers."

The outcome of the judgment has far-reaching implications for consumers and retailers across the UK and provides important clarifications on the protections available to people buying electronic goods at a distance. It would also be welcome news to the European Commission, considering that the Regulations 2013 implemented the EU'S Consumer Rights Directive 2011 and having regard to the Commission's work on promoting consumers in online transactions. 

Professor Teela Sanders, Pro Vice-Chancellor and Head of the University’s College of Social Sciences, Arts and Humanities, said: “This is a fantastic achievement for Ben and an excellent example of the real-world impact of the expertise we have here at Leicester. His legal knowledge and skill have contributed to a judgment with the potential to make a meaningful difference to consumers across the country and possibly the EU.

“It also gives us a powerful example to bring into our teaching, showing our students how the law they study at Leicester can be applied to real cases and have an impact on people’s everyday lives.”

The Court of Appeal handed down its decision on 13 November 2026.

  • The case is Dr Ebenezer Adodo v Argos Limited [2026] EWCA Civ 1462. Dr Ebenezer Adodo is Associate Professor of Commercial Law at Leicester Law School, University of Leicester. The judgment is available through The National Archives’ Find Case Law service and BAILII.